Muhammad provided answers to questions that only a true prophet could know, proving his prophethood.

The narrative from al-Bukhari presents Muhammad answering questions that are claimed to be known only by a prophet. However, the answers he provided, particularly regarding the biological process of child resemblance, reflect a misunderstanding of genetics. This scientific blunder raises doubts about his prophetic claims. Additionally, the assertion that the Jews would lie about Abdullah's conversion introduces a logical fallacy, as it assumes dishonesty without evidence, thus weakening the credibility of the entire account. Furthermore, the context in which these claims are made suggests a motive to validate Muhammad's status rather than provide an objective truth about his prophethood. In light of these issues, the narrative fails to establish Muhammad as a true prophet.