Muhammad did not order the killings of Asma bint Marwan and Abu Afak; these stories are fabricated to tarnish his image.

The article presents historical evidence from early Islamic texts, particularly from Ibn Ishaq's _Sirat Rasulullah_, which detail the circumstances surrounding the deaths of Asma bint Marwan and Abu Afak. These accounts describe how Muhammad reacted to criticism and mockery, leading to the orders for their assassinations. The narratives highlight the political and social context of early Islam, where dissent was met with lethal consequences. Furthermore, the responses from contemporary Muslims attempting to dismiss these accounts often lack engagement with the primary sources, which undermines their credibility. By examining these historical records, one can see a different aspect of Muhammad's character that contrasts sharply with the image of him as a peaceful prophet.