Christian scholars like John Fenton agree that the New Testament's interpretation of the Old Testament is flawed and that it does not accurately predict future events.

Jamal Badawi cites John C. Fenton to suggest that the New Testament's interpretation of the Old Testament is misguided. However, Fenton's actual argument acknowledges that Matthew believed in the prophetic fulfillment of the Old Testament through Jesus, even if modern scholarship questions the specifics of that interpretation. Fenton notes that Matthew's understanding was shaped by his context and audience, which is crucial for understanding the intent behind the Gospel. Furthermore, while Fenton critiques Matthew's methodology, he does not dismiss the belief in prophetic fulfillment, which is central to Christian doctrine. Thus, the claim that the New Testament lacks a valid interpretation of the Old Testament overlooks the historical and theological significance that Christians attribute to these texts.