The Hebrew Bible teaches that all prophets, including Jesus, were Muslims and that their message aligns with Islamic theology.

The assertion that all Biblical prophets were Muslims is fundamentally flawed because it overlooks the unique identity and mission of Jesus Christ as the Messiah. The Hebrew Bible presents a clear distinction between the roles of prophets and the divine nature of the Messiah, which is not compatible with Islamic theology. For instance, while the Quran claims that Jesus and the prophets were Muslims, the New Testament reveals that Jesus claimed divinity and established a new covenant, which is a pivotal aspect of Christian faith. Furthermore, the Hebrew Bible contains prophecies about the coming of the Messiah that are fulfilled in Jesus, such as Isaiah 9:6, which describes the Messiah as 'Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.' This understanding of the Messiah is absent in Islamic teachings, which do not recognize Jesus as divine. Therefore, the claim that the Hebrew Bible aligns more closely with the Quran than with Christian doctrine is not substantiated by the texts themselves.