Muslims might say that the Psalms do not clearly indicate the divinity of the Messiah, as they can be interpreted in various ways.

In Psalm 45, the Psalmist describes a King whose qualities and attributes are extraordinary, suggesting a nature that transcends ordinary humanity. The use of terms such as 'O God' and the declaration of an eternal throne imply a divine status. Furthermore, the Psalmist attributes actions and characteristics to this King that are traditionally associated with God, such as love for righteousness and the ability to execute justice. This blending of divine attributes with the description of the King indicates that the Messiah holds a unique position that aligns with the divine nature. Moreover, the language used in the Psalm stretches the limits of human description, indicating that the Psalmist is not merely speaking of a human king but is pointing towards a greater truth about the Messiah. The references to the sword and arrows, which are also attributed to God in other Psalms, further reinforce this connection. The Psalmist's celebration of the King’s qualities mirrors the descriptions of God, suggesting that the Messiah embodies divine characteristics. Additionally, the prophetic hints found in the Hebrew Scriptures align with the Christian understanding of the Messiah as divine. The consistent portrayal of the King in Psalm 45 as possessing attributes of God serves as a strong argument for the divinity of the Messiah, challenging the notion that these texts can be interpreted solely as references to a human ruler. Thus, the evidence within the Psalms supports the Christian claim of the Messiah's divine nature.