Muslims might argue that the concept of the Messiah's preexistence is not supported in the Hebrew Scriptures.

The Septuagint, a Greek translation of the Hebrew Scriptures, provides significant insight into Jewish beliefs about the Messiah, including the notion of His eternal reign. For instance, Psalm 72 in the Septuagint suggests that the Messiah's dominion is everlasting, indicating that He must possess an eternal nature to rule an eternal kingdom. This aligns with Christian teachings about Jesus Christ, who is seen as the fulfillment of these Messianic prophecies. Furthermore, Jewish scholars, such as Rashi, have interpreted passages like Micah 5:2 to imply the preexistence of the Messiah, suggesting that this understanding was present in Jewish thought long before the advent of Christianity. Therefore, the argument that the Messiah's preexistence is unsupported in the Hebrew Scriptures overlooks the rich tradition of interpretation that affirms this belief.