Salvation
God entrusted the protection of previous revelations to the religious leaders, but they failed, while He personally preserves the Quran.
Quick answer
The assertion that God entrusted the preservation of previous revelations to religious leaders is not supported by the text. Both the Quran and previous scriptures were entrusted to humans, and the claim that the Quran has been perfectly preserved is contradicted by evidence of variant readings and historical accounts.
Full argument
Jamal Badawi argues that the Quran is preserved by God while previous revelations were entrusted to fallible religious leaders who failed in their duty. However, the verse cited does not indicate that the Jews failed to preserve their scriptures; it merely states that they were entrusted with it. This is similar to how the Quran was entrusted to Muslims, who also played a role in its collection and compilation. Badawi's assumption that Allah used infallible men to compile the Quran is not substantiated by evidence. In fact, historical records and Quranic manuscripts show that the Quran has numerous variant readings, indicating that it has not been preserved without alteration. Furthermore, the Quran itself acknowledges attempts to tamper with its message, suggesting that changes occurred even during the Prophet's lifetime. This raises questions about the claim of divine preservation of the Quran compared to previous revelations.
Key verses
S. 5:44quran
for to them was entrusted the protection of Allah's book, and they were witnesses thereto
S. 15:9quran
We will assuredly guard it (from corruption)
S. 75:16-17quran
It is for Us to collect it and to recite it
S. 15:90-93quran
Those who made the Quran INTO SHREDS
Related articles
More in Salvation
- The Bible condones rape because it instructs a rapist to marry his victim in Deuteronomy 22:28-29.
- Jesus says that the Father is greater than he is, which proves that he cannot be God.
- Jesus himself admitted that the Father is the only true God, which proves that he denied being God.
- If Yahweh was the one true God who alone created the heavens and the earth and sent Jesus as his servant, then how can Jesus be God?
- How can Jesus be God when he will be in eternal subjection to God as stated in 1 Corinthians 15:28?