Muslims believe that the concept of Jesus being called 'Mighty God' contradicts the strict monotheism of Islam.

The Hebrew Bible presents a prophetic vision of a coming Messiah who is described with divine titles, such as 'Mighty God' (El Gibbor) and 'Eternal Father.' This is significant because these titles are traditionally reserved for Yahweh alone, indicating that the Messiah shares in the divine nature. For instance, Isaiah 9:6-7 speaks of a child born who will govern and whose name includes 'Mighty God,' suggesting a unique divine authority. Furthermore, Jeremiah 23:5-6 refers to the Messiah as 'YHVH Tseidkenu,' or 'The Lord is our righteousness,' further affirming His divine identity. Additionally, Micah 5:2 highlights the eternal nature of the Messiah, stating that His origins are from 'days of eternity.' This aligns with the Christian understanding of Jesus as pre-existent and divine, as articulated in John 1:1, which states, 'In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.' Thus, the prophetic writings not only affirm the divinity of the Messiah but also establish a continuity between the Old Testament and the New Testament understanding of Jesus. In contrast to Islamic teachings, which emphasize strict monotheism without the concept of a divine Messiah, the Christian interpretation sees the fulfillment of these prophecies in Jesus Christ. The New Testament writers, including the Apostle Paul, affirm this understanding by recognizing Jesus as the embodiment of God’s promises and the fulfillment of the law and the prophets. Therefore, the Christian belief in Jesus as 'Mighty God' does not contradict monotheism but rather enriches the understanding of God's nature and His plan for redemption.