Deity of Christ
According to Jesus, only God is good, yet Jesus calls himself good. How can Christians claim Jesus is divine when others are also called good?
Quick answer
Christians argue that Jesus was not denying his goodness but rather prompting a deeper understanding of his identity. The use of different Greek words for 'good' does not negate Jesus' claim to divinity, as he identifies himself as the good Shepherd, a title attributed to God in the Old Testament.
Full argument
First, knowledgeable Christians do not refer to John 10:11 to prove that Jesus is God merely because he applies the word 'good' to himself. Instead, they use it to counter the claim that Jesus was denying his essential goodness in the Synoptic Gospels. The argument that Jesus' statement in Matthew, Mark, and Luke disproves his divinity is a misunderstanding of his intent. Jesus was questioning the man's reasoning, leading him to realize that he was, in essence, claiming Jesus is God.
Moreover, a careful reading of John 10:11 and 14 reveals that Jesus identifies himself as the good Shepherd, a role that the Old Testament attributes to Yahweh. This connection strengthens the argument for Jesus' divinity, as he aligns himself with God's shepherding role over His people.
The distinction between the Greek words 'kalos' and 'agathos' does not undermine Jesus' claim to goodness or divinity. The context of Jesus' statements emphasizes his unique role and identity, which transcends mere moral goodness. Thus, the argument that other individuals being called good somehow equates them with God is a misapplication of the logic involved.
In conclusion, the assertion that Jesus' statements contradict his divinity fails to recognize the deeper theological implications of his self-identification as the good Shepherd, which is consistent with the nature of God as revealed in Scripture.
Key verses
John 10:11bible
I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep.
Psalm 23:1bible
The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want.
Matthew 19:17bible
And he said to him, 'Why do you ask me about what is good? There is only one who is good.'
Related articles
More in Deity of Christ
- The Bible condones rape because it instructs a rapist to marry his victim in Deuteronomy 22:28-29.
- Muslims believe that Jesus cannot be God because God is the only eternal ruler and king.
- Muslims might say that the Lord's Prayer does not indicate the divinity of Jesus, as it emphasizes praying to the Father alone.
- Muslims believe that Jesus is not the Son of God and that he is not equal to God.
- Muslims might argue that hell was created for all humanity, and that God's justice requires punishment for all who sin.